Designing a National Survey of Retail Investors After the Surveillance Debate – A Case Study

Designing a National Survey of Retail Investors After the Surveillance Debate – A Case Study

In November 2026, Meridian Insight Group, a US market research firm, wins a $2 million federal contract. It must find out how retail investors in American equity markets have been affected by the debate over government surveillance of their trading, centred on the SEC’s Consolidated Audit Trail. The brief is thin. It asks for “nationally credible evidence” but defines neither “affected” nor the population, and sets no precision targets. Stakeholders raise competing concerns: market participation, trust, hidden harm to vulnerable investors, and one headline number for Congress. With eleven days to submit a design memo that must also clear federal review, managing director Dana Whitfield weighs rival proposals. They include qualitative exploration, an address-based probability survey, and a large opt-in online sample with a framing experiment, all complicated by the lack of a baseline. Students must derive the research questions from the setting, then build and defend a research design within budget.

Download the case study now

Teaching Objectives

  1. Show that research design starts with problem definition. Distinguish the management dilemma from the research problem, and research questions from investigative questions.
  2. Show how the type of question (exploratory, descriptive or causal) shapes design choices, including sequential mixed-methods designs.
  3. Examine trade-offs among sampling frame, mode, coverage, nonresponse and cost when the attitude being measured also predicts who responds.
  4. Highlight measurement validity for sensitive, politically charged constructs: framing, sponsor effects, social desirability and recall error.
  5. Explore how to estimate “impact” without a baseline, using retrospective items, secondary benchmarks, panels and survey experiments.
  6. Raise research ethics and stakeholder credibility in government-sponsored research.

Learning Outcomes

By the end of the case, students will be able to:

  1. Derive research and investigative questions from an ambiguous brief and competing stakeholder concerns, and separate what a survey can answer from what it cannot. (Assessed in Q1)
  2. Classify research questions by the kind of knowledge they need, and justify an overall design logic. (Q2)
  3. Calculate sample sizes using design effects and subgroup precision targets, and evaluate sampling frames and modes for coverage, nonresponse bias and cost. (Q3, Q4)
  4. Identify and mitigate measurement threats, including framing effects, in sensitive survey items. (Q3)
  5. Compare approaches to estimating impact and judge their internal and external validity. (Q2, Q4)
  6. Allocate a fixed research budget across research questions and defend the trade-offs to a sceptical stakeholder. (Q4)
  7. Weigh the ethical obligations of researching people about surveillance, including confidentiality, informed consent and respondent burden. (Q5)

Leave a Reply